
Our Story of Faith
Our story begins not with a building, but with a small group of people hungry for prayer and connection. In 1800, Jacob Albright united a group of believers in Pennsylvania to spend Sundays in worship and Wednesdays in prayer. Driven by a desire to share the good news of Jesus, Gospel Circuit Riders carried this movement westward across the frontier into the Dakota Territory.
Pioneer Roots in Jamestown (1883–1914)
In April 1883, a young, earnest pastor named Rev. William Suckow arrived in the Jamestown mission by horse and buggy. Traveling across miles of open prairie, he met with families in their homes, determined to build a community of faith where German-speaking pioneers could worship in their native tongue.
That dedication bore fruit in the summer of 1884, when Rev. F.W. Tesch led the congregation in building their first mission church. As the congregation grew spiritually and numerically, new ministries took root:
-
1894: Under the leadership of Rev. and Mrs. Julius Fandrey, St. Paul’s launched its first Sunday School, formed a choir, and hosted its first community Christmas program.
-
Early 1900s: Members worked together to expand their ministry space, excavating a basement and renovating the sanctuary to welcome more neighbors.
Mission Church - 1884
Expanding Our Reach (1915–1943)
By 1914, the congregation had outgrown its original mission church. In 1915, St. Paul’s relocated a larger building to the corner of 2nd Ave. and 4th St. SW (today the southwest corner of Hugo’s parking lot), turning the original mission building into a parsonage.
The decades that followed marked significant milestones in how we served our community:
-
Youth & Discipleship: Under Rev. R.E. Strutz (1918–1926), the church organized its first catechism class and expanded the basement to make room for a growing youth group and Sunday School.
-
Welcoming New Neighbors: While services were originally held exclusively in German, a growing number of English-speaking neighbors began attending. Recognizing the need to share the gospel with everyone in the community, St. Paul’s transitioned to English worship services.
-
Growing Ministries: Between 1936 and 1943, under Rev. Otto Felberg, every department of the church saw growth. The congregation renovated the sanctuary, built a dedicated prayer meeting room, and completed a fellowship kitchen. By 1943, St. Paul’s had grown to 180 members and celebrated becoming a fully self-supporting congregation.
The purchased old Methodist Episcopal Church Building - 1915
The congregation of St. Paul's in the 1940's
Building for the Future (1945–1976)
Following World War II, St. Paul’s continued to invest in community outreach and Christian education. During the late 1940s, the church received a generous gift from the estate of Mr. Beck, a local Jewish businessman who left funds to every church in Jamestown. That gift was used to purchase the congregation's Hammond organ.
In the 1950s, under Rev. Ira Herzberg, the church acquired neighboring homes to serve as additional Sunday School classrooms, and a planning committee began dreaming of a permanent home that could accommodate the growing congregation.
That dream became reality in the early 1960s under the leadership of Rev. Kenneth K. Koth, a son of the congregation:
-
June 5, 1961: Hundreds of members gathered at 1000 5th Ave. NE to break ground on a new 22,000-square-foot church.
-
August 19, 1962: Following a final brief service in the old building, Rev. Koth led the congregation—escorted by the Jamestown Police—in a historic walk to their new church home, where worship continued.
-
September 2, 1962: With membership now at 389 people, St. Paul’s dedicated the new building and opened its doors to the entire Jamestown community. Built through countless hours of volunteer labor, the bell tower still houses our original 1898 church bell, calling people to worship just as it did over a century ago.
By 1976, the congregation celebrated the complete payoff of the new building with a joyful service of rededication, leaving St. Paul’s free to focus entirely on ministry and mission.
Original Artist's Rendering of the 1962 Building
The Church Completed in 1962
Our Story Continues Today
For more than 140 years, St. Paul’s has been shaped by generations of believers willing to step out in faith, adapt to serve their neighbors, and share the love of Christ. From a handful of pioneers gathering in prairie homes to a thriving congregation in the heart of Jamestown, God has been faithful every step of the way—and our best chapters are still ahead.
Today, we carry that same spirit forward as a traditional neighborhood church where lives are transformed by Jesus, united in our shared mission to make disciples of Jesus Christ for the transformation of the world. We invite you to become part of the next chapter of our faith story!
Create Your Own Website With Webador